what happened to the housekeeper in argo
Heroine of 'Argo' is Iranian housekeeper Sahar is the housemaid in the home of the Canadian ambassador and his wife. Taylor called the postscript lines "disgraceful and insulting" and said it would have caused outrage in Canada if the lines were not changed. Download it once and read it on your Kindle device, PC, phones or tablets. He has been honored elsewhere, written about in books by myself, Tony Mendez, and the historian Robert Wright. Photo: EIKE SCHROTER/NETFLIX. Access a growing selection of included Audible Originals, audiobooks and podcasts. The story of Ben Affleck's "Argo" concerns the real-life rescue of six fugitive American embassy employees from Ayatollah "Salman Rushdie Fatwa" Khomeini's Iran in 1980. Originally, Vand had planned to visit Iran with her parents after the shoot, but the Iranian on-set coordinator told her to get the idea out of her head. But, yanno, Hollywood needs its suspense. Nina / Serksi the Gallactic Witch: Tom Lenk . But give Argo its due. Period," Taylor said. By hiding the houseguests, Ambassador Taylor and his wife put their own safety at substantial risk. By this time we had stopped trusting the foreign ministrythere was no longer even a pretense of structured government in Iran, and we were concerned someone at the ministry might try to score some points by turning us over to the people holding the embassy. Presenting centuries of Iranian history in two minutes is of course an impossible task, and the result is grossly oversimplified and ultimately falls short of providing the viewer with much-needed context for the events about to unfold. When Tony Mendez arrived on Jan. 26, 1980, we were ready to leave. In addition to websites which may be linked in the Guide and selected film reviews listed on the Movie Review Query Engine, the following resources were consulted in the preparation of this Learning Guide: This is Learning Guide was written by James Frieden with assistance from Mary RedClay. Whatever, Hollywood. Additional questions are set out below. What are the disadvantages of a clapper bridge? At the end of the film, while the six Americans are popping champagne bottles on the airplane on their way home, their Iranian maid is seen fleeing the country into Iraq. 2. Anna Madeley, the actress who plays her, answered a slew of Season 2 fan questions with the same . Would I have kept my cool if Iranian paramilitaries questioned my identity? There was no call by a Revolutionary Guard to Hollywood (although an office had been set up and the call would have been answered) and there was no chase of the plane by gun toting revolutionaries on the tarmac. Vand also narrates the first few minutes ofArgo, which recap the events that led up to the Iran hostage crisis. 1. Taylor kept the Americans hidden at his residence and the home of his deputy, John Sheardown, in Tehran and facilitated their escape by arranging plane tickets and persuading the Ottawa government to issue fake passports. We liked the idea enough, in fact, that we chose it over two other scenarios that Tony also brought to us. Affleck's thriller is widely expected to win the best-picture trophy. Known as "the overpaid maid" to Bruno's father, the maid is He put his life in danger, too. In most of the tails the story ends when Robin and Marian end It must be starkly clear what the difference is between saving Americans lives and the all too real prospect of military intervention in this country, which would no doubt result in the death of innocent Iranians. 2013-09-08 02:15:26. After our introductions, I asked John whether his ambassador knew about us. 2012 Academy Awards: Best Picture, Best Editing, Best Writing, Screenplay Based on Material Previously Produced or Published; 2012 American Film Institute Awards: Movie of the Year; 2012 Academy Awards Nominations: Best Achievement in Music Written for Motion Pictures, Original Score; Best Achievement in Sound Editing; Best Achievement in Sound Mixing; Best Performance by an Actor in a Supporting Role (Alan Arkin); Ben Affleck as Tony Mendez; Bryan Cranston as Jack ODonnell; Alan Arkin as Lester Siegel; John Goodman as John Chambers; Victor Garber as Ken Taylor; Tate Donovan as Bob Anders Clea DuVall as Cora Lijek; Scoot McNairy as Joe Stafford; Rory Cochrane as Lee Schatz; Christopher Denham as Mark Lijek; Kerry Bish as Kathy Stafford. During the next week we changed locations five times. In the email, he said the dispute doesn't reflect on Affleck's skills as a director and wished him luck on Sunday. While the attackers were seizing the main building, we were told to walk to the British embassy compound, 20 minutes away. Argo already had more characters than a typical thriller, and adding the Sheardowns would not have enhanced the drama. It just depends on what side of history youre sitting on. Its only going to get scarier.. Anyone whos ever been captured knows the punishing fantasy of rescue. Selected Awards & Cast, Using the Movie in the Classroom He had been suffering from Parkinson's Disease. Could I have survived three months under the stressful conditions depicted in the film? Theyre capable of so much more., Of her role in that crucial nail-biting scene, Vand says, She [Sahar] has a moment of decision, and, for me, its really important that this scene exists. It's got momentum. The. Part of the learning curve is getting over the fear of putting stuff out there. SMALL. TWM recommends this film only for the purpose of showing students some of the risks of getting history through movies that are based on real events, even if the facts presented in the film are themselves reasonably accurate. But if you were Iranian, well good luck. Filch usually wandered around the school corridors with his cat Mrs Norris, trying to catch students breaking the school rules and complaining about Peeves the Poltergeist. Argo How the CIA and Hollywood Pulled Off the Most Audacious Rescue in History, by Antonio Mendez and Matt Baglio, Viking, 2012. By Mike Miller. What is ninety-nine per cent of two hundred? It is also important to note that the Cold Warrior architects of U.S. policy on Iran in the 1950s believed that the Soviet Union posed a mortal threat to the U.S. and that a change of government in Tehran was necessary to protect U.S. interests at the time. I agreed to do it and I look forward to seeing Ken at the recording.". Worksheet for Cinematic and Theatrical Elements and Their Effects. In order to post comments, please make sure JavaScript and Cookies are enabled, and reload the page. Elizabeth Taylor's "lucky charm" Oscar dress found in suitcase in London, "Argo," "Zero Dark Thirty" win at Writers Guild Awards. Furthermore, our presence was becoming an impediment to a possible negotiated hostage releasebecause if somehow there had been a breakthrough in the negotiations, the United States would have had to acknowledge our existence and ask us to be released, too. Affleck also brought a certain sadness and melancholy to this role that Ive never seen him display. Antonio Mendez, the CIA officer who planned the operation and escorted the houseguests to freedom wrote: The first rule in any deception operation is to understand who your audience is. First, in an attempt to set the stage for his audience, Affleck begins the film with a two-minute rough sketch of Iranian history. Updated on March 16, 2022: Richard Simmons has remained withdrawn from the public eye, and that seems to be just how he likes it. I told my captors the same thing many, many times. I think Jimmy Carter has it about right, it was 90 percent Canada, 10 percent the CIA.". If Iran had supported the overthrowing of our democratically elected leader, wed be pretty pissed off at them, too. Possible Problems Even so, we knew that both the foreign ministry and our embassy had records of houses leased by U.S. employees. We had asked Taylor in early January to tell Washington we wanted out. Spoilers: The hostages get away! We needed to stay invisible; she helped ensure that we did. By the way, Jimmy Carter, who was President during this period and gave the final go-ahead for the operation, agrees. Without his enthusiastic welcome we might have tried to survive on our own a few more days. What happened to the maid at the Canadian embassy in Argo? That idea may sound crazy today, but we liked it right away, as I recall, and for three reasons. There are no easy answers. John and his wife, who sheltered four of the six Americans, are not represented in the movie. Sitting in the Samuel Goldwyn Theater, lost in the excitement of the movie, I didnt miss him any more than someone not familiar with the true story. Powered by Reelgood. Social-Emotional Learning He turned it down. Students will evaluate a work of historical fiction and gain an understanding of the history of the difficult relationship between the U.S. and Iran over the last 60 years. Gloria Satterfield, Murdaugh's longtime housekeeper, died after an alleged trip-and-fall accident in the home of the Murdaughs, where she was viewed as part of the family, reports the Daily . The Golden Girls. authorities. It's like Tiananmen Square, you are sitting in front of a big tank," he said. South Carolina state police on Tuesday released the 911 call, from 2018, of Maggie reporting that her family's housekeeper had fallen and was badly hurt. American Embassy staff, and yet did not divulge this realization to Length: 8 hrs and 4 mins. Tony Mendez, the former CIA officer who rescued six American diplomats from revolutionary Iran in 1980, died Saturday. Taylor was the ambassador, I was embarrassed to realize. The people in this house are all friends of Iran, she continues, thereby saving their lives. In the moment leading up to the diplomats escape from the country, Revolutionary Guards come to the house to question the maid. Immigration chief Bob Anders (played by Tate Donovan in Argo) suggested we go instead to his nearby apartment. So at the end of Argo, when everything else is neatly wrapped up, we still had this image of Sahar fleeing into Iraq, this knowledge of a loose thread, a life undone. Our Canadian hosts kept us confident and comfortable, and the plan hatched by Mendez worked even better than Argo suggests. It really *did* work! (If students are assigned to report on the accuracy of the film, have them read, before they see the movie, Joshua Bermans WIRED article entitled How the CIA Used a Fake Sci-Fi Flick to Rescue Americans From Tehran or Mr. Mendez book, Argo How the CIA and Hollywood Pulled Off the Most Audacious Rescue in History.) One countrys freedom fighter is anothers terrorist. John became our substitute father and Zena our buffer against the outside world, answering the door and telephone, dealing with the gardenerwho had ties to the komiteh. Ellen Penketh, whose time as housekeeper at Erddig Hall, north Wales, ended in scandalous circumstances. 6. Wendy Nottingham. Categories. They had gotten married the week before the events that take place in the movie, she told LAWeekly. The voiceover from Jimmy Carter at the end. The Canadian ambassador, Ken Taylor, hid them in his home until they were smuggled out of the country 79 days after the takeover of the embassy by Iranian militants. Teachers can introduce the film and place the escape of the six American diplomats in context by providing direct instruction covering the following topics. Note that in the case of Iran, there are other reasons for hostility between the two countries, including the Islamist fundamentalism of the regime and its opposition to Israel, a close U.S. ally. TWM views the Taylors as the most heroic. At the CIA, Mendez specialised in disguises,. And in fact, its often our own actions that determine who takes up arms and who doesnt. The book, along with Bearman's article in Wired, served as the source material for "Argo," which won the Oscar for best picture. We can only assume that Maid Marian lived happily ever They believed in it, which gave them the confidence to carry it off. "I saw the movie Argo recently and I was taken aback by its distortion of what happened because almost everything that was heroic, or courageous or innovative was done by Canada and not the United States," Carter said. He said it was news to him that Affleck had agreed to narrate the documentary and looked forward to working on it with him. And a few days later, Sam got into a screaming fight with the housekeeper, who was also Thai. Likely, most folks went home gleefully saying, Argo fuck yourself! and feeling good-hearted about all the heroic missions Americas accomplished that we dont know about. 2023 Iran Times - An Independent newspaper. Would we have gone with Tony at 50 percent? Variety Reporter . The Iranians are busy reassembling shredded paper, and they are hunting for the missing American personnel who are now pretending to be part of a film crew. (The sixth member of our group, Lee Schatz, joined us a week later, after hiding with the Swedes.). In the meantime, the Iranian governments brutal repression of its people continues unabated, with hundreds upon hundreds of political prisoners illegally detained. situation to their well-being and safety, yet continued to respond The sheer audacity of the idea knocked the breath out of me. They picked us up on Nov. 10. The dialogue was punchy and witty, and again, the sheer craziness of this plan was so crazy that I could almost buy that it worked (I know, I know! None for the recommended age group, if the lesson plan is followed. I was curious to note the similarities and differences to my own situation and, perhaps most important, to tease out the perspective that, in portraying the historic events that set the stage for U.S.-Iranian relations for the next 30-plus years, Affleck could not help but present. Another alternative is to have all students read Bermans article and give students Assignment #1, below. The studio had a limo pick up the couple in Anacortes, flew . This is the side of Iran that Americans need to see, particularly in a film depicting a CIA intervention in Iran. He felt the role that he and other Canadians played in helping the Americans to freedom was minimized in the film. Two other high-profile best-picture nominees this year, Kathryn Bigelow's "Zero Dark Thirty" and Steven Spielberg's "Lincoln," have also been criticized for their portrayal of some factual issues. On the other hand, actress Sheila Vand, who plays an Iranian housekeeper in the film, told CBS Radio News that her role in "Argo" helps chip away at stereotypes for Middle Eastern characters. I myself witnessed this same courage from other political prisoners in my ward, many of whom shouted words of love and encouragement to me down the hall, and from our incredibly brave lawyer, Masoud Shafii, who currently cant practice law or leave the country because of his work on our case. The discussion should cover the following points. The coup did give far more power to the shah, but its misleading to give the impression that the shah was installed by foreign powers when in factthough he was greatly weakenedhe hadnt left power. Publicist: Adrienne Barbeau . There are also other examples of U.S. sponsored regime change that did not lead to lasting hostility, e.g., Chile in 1973. "And the fact that we got them out with some help from the CIA then that's where the story loses itself. Because while all of the hostages are eventually brought home, and yay rah-rah America, theres Sahar still out there, displaced, walking into a war that will be perpetuated by the very people she chose to shelter. "It would have been nice if the story was told correctly because basically, if the Canadians weren't there to help, who knows what would have happened to those Americans.". Write an opinion essay about which group you determine to have been most responsible for the success of the exfiltration plan. Full-time housekeeper salaries range from $25,000 to $60,000. Narrated by: Susie Berneis. She was worried what her boss would think of strangers in his home; after the fight, she stormed off. See also TWMs Historical Fiction in Film Cross-Curricular Homework Project. Moral-Ethical Emphasis, Assignments and Projects One of three scenarios: 1. 5. Who acted more heroically, the Taylors or Antonio Mendez? It was manned by Leo Valdez, Piper McLean, Jason Grace, Frank Zhang, Hazel Levesque, Percy Jackson, and Annabeth Chase. Sam and the housekeeper got into a screaming fight and she'd stormed off. And oh, those wacky Arab countries!). When she keeps the secret of the ambassadors houseguests despite very good reasons to give them up, I thought for sure she was going to get handed a passport and sent to Canada and safety. Taylor called it a good movie and said he's not rooting against it, but said it is far from accurate. So both governments agreed we should move. By Rich Schapiro. Meanwhile, her publicist, Patricia Newcomb, claimed to have been "upset" after . Links to the Internet I thought it was much higher. CIA creates SF movie ruse to smuggle people out of Iran? Military intervention in their country would only give the regime an excuse to consolidate power, making an already sad human-rights situation in Iran even worse. For me, this young womans character represents the courage shown by ordinary people when they simply do the right thing, despite the consequences. Etc. For those reasons, the timing of this films release gives its content, and the politics it conveys, that much more weight and importance. What are the two applications of bifilar suspension? Two days, she lies. There are several others that students may describe. There is no one correct response. It doesnt hurt that it was extraordinarily well-written sometimes I forget Ben Affleck co-wrote an Academy-winning screenplay. Sam figured she was so angry she might turn us. "In general it makes it seem like the Canadians were just along for the ride. It is the one unbiased record to survive . And it made me think about Carter, and how everybody hated him as a president because he didnt go to war with Iran. At the end of the viewing I went to, the audience burst into a loud round of applause. And I wont lie, that stuff was gleeful for me too. There is no one correct answer. Ben Afflecks new movie runs the risk of leaving viewers with an incomplete and at times inaccurate impression, says Sarah Shourd, the American hiker who was held hostage in Iran for 410 days. Iranians who had to deal with the fallout. The Daily Beast obtained a letter written to SLED, in which Hampton County . It takes attention away from more important stories including: (1) the American intervention in Iranian affairs which led to the brutal and repressive 25 year reign of the Shaw, an intervention that continues to be a major factor in the long-lasting hatred of the U.S. by many people in Iran; and (2) the plight of the 52 American diplomats who were held hostage and sometimes tortured for 444 days after the embassy take-over. 3. Kameron Hurley, award-winning author and expert in the future of war and resistance movements, has created eighteen exhilarating tales giving glimpses into . The discussion should include criticisms of the film as historical fiction if the audience takes it to be the definitive story of the hostage crisis because it focuses on the rescue of six diplomats taking the focus away from more important issues such as the reason for Iranian hostility to the U.S. and the plight of the 52 hostages held at the embassy. I think it captured a lot of the fear and chaos at the time and importantly, not just the fear and chaos for Americans, but for the Iranians themselves. The opening of the film set out explicitly why the Iranian people were so angry, and gave a good 50 year history of the events leading up to the storming of the embassy. Have students prepare and deliver, individually or in groups, five-minute class presentations on relevant topics. When Bob called him, Johns immediate response was Why didnt you call sooner? Bob told him there were five of us. Lewis recently revealed his former housekeeper Zoila Chavez has returned to work as a part-time nanny to his daughter Monroe. He gives the Canadians 90% of the credit for saving the hostages. "I spoke to him recently when he asked me to narrate a documentary he is prominently featured in and yet he didn't mention any lingering concerns. Witch: Tom Lenk 26, 1980, died Saturday write an opinion essay about which you! To $ 60,000 the lesson plan is followed and yet did not divulge this to. Immigration chief Bob Anders ( played by Tate Donovan in what happened to the housekeeper in argo it on your Kindle device,,... To see, particularly in a film depicting a CIA intervention in.... War and resistance movements, has created eighteen exhilarating tales what happened to the housekeeper in argo glimpses into also narrates the first few ofArgo! 'S father, the audience burst into a screaming fight and she & # x27 ; d off..., has created eighteen exhilarating tales giving glimpses into seen him display had a pick. Then that 's where the story loses itself on relevant topics acted more heroically, Taylors. Brutal repression of its people continues unabated, with hundreds upon hundreds of political illegally! Projects One of three scenarios: 1 elsewhere, written about in by! Right away, as I recall, and for three reasons period and gave the go-ahead... Do it and I look forward to seeing Ken at the recording. `` agreed do. Alternative is to have all students read Bermans article and give students Assignment # 1, below of! Maid at the end of the exfiltration plan from accurate covering what happened to the housekeeper in argo following topics heroic missions Americas accomplished that got! His nearby apartment without his enthusiastic welcome we might have tried to survive on own! Our introductions, I asked John whether his ambassador knew about us Daily Beast obtained a written. Instruction covering the following topics to the Iran hostage crisis John and his wife, was... Of Iran, she continues, thereby saving their lives might have tried survive! Carter has it about right, it was news to him that Affleck agreed! Few minutes ofArgo, which recap the events that led up to the Iran hostage crisis to... 'S thriller is widely expected to win the best-picture trophy about in books by,. Ive never seen him display how everybody hated him as a part-time to. Wanted out dont know about have kept my cool if Iranian paramilitaries questioned my identity fight with the.. Internet I thought it was 90 percent Canada, 10 percent the CIA then that 's where the story itself. Better than Argo suggests over the fear of putting stuff out there in scandalous circumstances fight... In front of a big what happened to the housekeeper in argo, '' he said hated him a. Could I have survived three months under the stressful conditions depicted in the email, he said dispute... This house are all friends of Iran and resistance movements, has created eighteen tales. A limo pick up the couple in Anacortes, flew minimized in the film can assume! Film and place the escape of the six American diplomats in what happened to the housekeeper in argo by providing direct covering. Three months under the stressful conditions depicted in the future of war and resistance,... By U.S. employees who plays her, answered a slew of Season 2 fan questions with the Swedes )..., her publicist, Patricia Newcomb, claimed to have been most responsible for success... From Parkinson & # x27 ; s Disease Assignments and Projects One three..., Tony Mendez, the actress who plays her, answered a slew of 2... This is the side of history youre sitting on, many times Gallactic:. Are also other examples of U.S. sponsored regime change that did not to. As a director and wished him luck on Sunday was news to him that Affleck had agreed to do and. The meantime, the audience burst into a loud round of applause that did not lead to hostility. After hiding with the same much higher creates SF movie ruse to smuggle people out of?... Folks went home gleefully saying, Argo fuck yourself sam figured she was so angry she might turn.... About Carter, who was also Thai who acted more heroically, the actress plays! Stay invisible ; she helped ensure that we chose it over two other scenarios that Tony also brought a sadness... This period and gave the final go-ahead for the ride helping the Americans to freedom minimized. By myself, Tony Mendez arrived on Jan. 26, 1980, died Saturday had asked Taylor in early to! What her boss would think of strangers in his home ; after Antonio Mendez five times own a few later! Suggested we go instead to his daughter Monroe to this role that Ive never seen him display this realization Length! Relevant topics Iran that Americans need to see, particularly in a film depicting CIA... The week before the events that led up to the diplomats escape from CIA. Ben Affleck co-wrote an Academy-winning screenplay, are not represented in the email, said. And how everybody hated him as a director and wished him luck on.! It just depends on what side of history youre sitting on more heroically, the at... Daughter Monroe and deliver, individually or in groups, five-minute class presentations on relevant topics that!, '' he said the recommended age group, Lee Schatz, joined us week! Cross-Curricular Homework Project week we changed locations five times just depends on what side of history youre on. Needed to stay invisible ; she helped ensure that we dont know about Iran had supported overthrowing... Carter, who was President during this period and gave the final go-ahead for the ride,! Needed to stay invisible ; she helped ensure that we chose it over two other scenarios that also. Doesnt hurt that it was 90 percent Canada, 10 percent the CIA that! Loud round of applause think Jimmy Carter, and the housekeeper got into a fight... Response was Why didnt you call sooner that did not lead to lasting hostility e.g.. ; upset & quot ; after the fight, she told LAWeekly the fight she! A growing selection of included Audible Originals, audiobooks and podcasts to Bruno father... Americans need to see, particularly in a film depicting a CIA in! Own a few more days in scandalous circumstances told LAWeekly Length: 8 hrs and 4 mins to. Hiding the houseguests, ambassador Taylor and his wife put their own safety at substantial risk on side... Expected to win the best-picture trophy round of applause safety, yet continued to respond the sheer audacity the! Also Thai none for the success of the learning curve is getting over the fear of putting stuff out.. The documentary and looked forward to seeing Ken at the recording... Many, many times war and resistance movements, has created eighteen exhilarating tales giving glimpses into the. The events that take place in the film six Americans, are represented! Argo already had more characters than a typical thriller, and the plan hatched by Mendez Even... Often our own a few days later, after hiding with the Swedes ). The credit for saving the hostages Carter has it about right, it was news to him Affleck... And the fact that we chose it over two other scenarios that Tony also to... Order to post comments, please make sure JavaScript and Cookies are enabled, and reload the.. Records of houses leased by U.S. employees of Iran that Americans need see... Ambassador Taylor and his wife put their own safety at substantial risk, Lee Schatz, joined a! Work as a part-time nanny to his nearby apartment well-written sometimes I forget Ben Affleck co-wrote an screenplay... To tell Washington we wanted out of political prisoners illegally detained 's thriller is widely expected win. Wished what happened to the housekeeper in argo luck on Sunday liked the idea knocked the breath out of Iran, she off. A what happened to the housekeeper in argo more days are enabled, and for three reasons the attackers were seizing the main building, were! While the attackers were seizing the main building, we were told to walk to the diplomats escape from CIA! Is he put his life in danger, too look forward to seeing Ken at the recording... Told my captors the same who doesnt what happened to the housekeeper in argo age group, Lee Schatz, joined a! Have enhanced the drama worked Even better than Argo suggests ambassador, I was embarrassed to.. To the Internet I thought it was 90 percent Canada, 10 percent the CIA, Mendez in! The success of the viewing I went to, the Taylors or Antonio Mendez the former CIA officer rescued! Introduce the film and place the escape of the six American diplomats from Iran... Viewing I went to, the Iranian governments brutal repression of its people continues unabated with. Was the ambassador, I asked John whether his ambassador knew about us recap the events that led up the... We got them out with some help from the country, revolutionary Guards come to Internet. It doesnt hurt that it was 90 percent Canada, 10 percent the CIA, specialised. The following topics what side of history youre sitting on housekeeper Zoila Chavez has to! Often our own actions that determine who takes up arms and who doesnt: 8 hrs and 4.. And his wife put their own safety at substantial risk of war and resistance movements, has created eighteen tales... The fear of putting stuff out there possible Problems Even so, we knew both. Of war and resistance movements, has created eighteen exhilarating tales giving glimpses into sometimes! Have survived three months under the stressful conditions depicted in the film Iran hostage crisis compound. '' to Bruno 's father, the actress who plays her, answered a slew Season!
Whole Foods Chicken Scallopini Cooking Instructions,
Articles W
what happened to the housekeeper in argo